Poor Relief and Welfare in Germany from the Reformation to World War I
Cambridge University Press, 16/10/2008
EAN 9780521506038, ISBN10: 0521506034
Hardcover, 272 pages, 23.6 x 16 x 2.4 cm
This account of poor relief, charity, and social welfare in Germany from the Reformation through World War I integrates historical narrative and theoretical analysis of such issues as social discipline, governmentality, gender, religion, and state-formation. It analyzes the changing cultural frameworks through which the poor came to be considered as needy; the institutions, strategies, and practices devised to assist, integrate, and discipline these populations; and the political alchemy through which the needs of the individual were reconciled with those of the community. While the Bismarckian social insurance programs have long been regarded as the origin of the German welfare state, this book shows how preventive social welfare programs - the second pillar of the welfare state - evolved out of traditional poor relief, and it emphasizes the role of progressive reformers and local, voluntary initiative in this process and the impact of competing reform discourses on both the social domain and the public sphere.
"This important work provides the first comprehensive history of German social policy from the early modern era until the First World War. A well-organized narrative that surveys all of Germany's many regions shows how charitable and religious approaches to poor relief evolved into Europe's most advanced welfare-state system. The author presents this complex process neither negatively as the repression of the lower classes nor over-optimistically as progress toward perfect social justice, but rather as a flawed but often well-intentioned attempt to integrate the poor into cities, communities, and the national state. This book will certainly become a standard work in its field, and it provides an indispensable basis for future research." -Ann Taylor Allen, University of Louisville "This book is an impressive synthesis. Drawing on archival, published, and secondary sources, Frohman presents a coherent and compelling account of the evolution of poor relief and welfare in Germany in the modern period. Frohman's analysis integrates cultural, institutional, and political history, local and national history, and offers a nuanced, thoughtful, and persuasive perspective on competing interpretive and theoretical frameworks. This book will be obligatory reading and a valuable resource for everyone interested in the history of the welfare state in Central Europe." -Edward Ross Dickinson, University of California at Davis "For the first time we have an authoritative general history of the treatment of the poor in Germany between the early modern era and the early twentieth century. Larry Frohman navigates expertly between those 'whiggish' readings of social policy that emphasize improvement, social integration, and the supports needed for productive citizenship and the darker story of social discipline, biopolitics, and the rationalizing drives of governmentality. His book will appeal not just to German historians, but to historians of social policy and social welfare across national fields and to sociologists and social work specialists too." -Geoff Eley, Karl Pohrt Distinguished University Professor of Contemporary History, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor "An ambitious, wide-ranging and intelligent book, successfully combining the history of relief institutions with the history of social theory. There is nothing in English or German that can match it." -E. P. Hennock, University of Liverpool "Frohman's study deepens our understandings of the German welfare state across an impressively long trajectory from the Reformation until the founding of the Weimar Republic. Suggesting a powerful place for poor relief in German solutions to the social question, Frohman offers definitive insights into the history of social citizenship as it emerged in the nineteenth century and as it was transformed by the rise of the nation-state, by liberalism and scientific social reform, and ultimately by the First World War." - Kathleen Canning, University of Michigan "Frohman traces the history of institutional responses to poverty from the 16th to the 20th century. The fact that the book is concerned with such a long period of time is one of its major strenghts. Recommended." -Choice